Current:Home > ScamsJurors can’t be replaced once deliberations begin, North Carolina appeals court rules-InfoLens
Jurors can’t be replaced once deliberations begin, North Carolina appeals court rules
View Date:2024-12-23 16:58:12
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A man sentenced to life in prison without parole for a fatal shooting in a Raleigh motel room was awarded a new trial on Tuesday by the state Court of Appeals because of a jury shakeup after deliberations began.
A panel of the intermediate-level appeals court unanimously agreed that Eric Ramond Chambers’ right to a “properly constituted jury” under the state constitution was violated.
Chambers was convicted of first-degree murder and a serious assault charge for the 2018 shooting that led to the death of Davelle McMoore and wounding of Terri Blossom.
After jury deliberations in Chambers’ 2022 trial began, a juror told Superior Court Judge Rebecca Holt that he could not return the next day due to a scheduled doctor’s appointment, according to Tuesday’s opinion.
Holt replaced the juror with an alternate and told the jury to begin its deliberations anew. Chambers, who was representing himself in the trial, was not in the courtroom when the substitution occurred.
The state constitution says, with some possible exceptions, no one can be convicted of any crime “but by the unanimous verdict of a jury in open court.” And the state Supreme Court has ruled that means juror substitution can’t occur after deliberations have started, Court of Appeals Chief Judge Chris Dillon wrote in the opinion.
Dillon said that tenet remains intact even with a 2021 law from the General Assembly that says an alternate can be used for deliberations if an original juror can’t continue, provided the jury is told to start their deliberations anew.
An attorney for the state defending the conviction said the juror argument couldn’t be pursued by Chambers because he failed to object to the substitution at trial. And the 2021 law comported with the state constitution in that it required a “jury of specifically twelve, operating from the same facts and law, unanimously determine a defendant’s guilt or innocence,” Assistant Attorney General Caden Hayes wrote.
But Chambers’ court-appointed appellate attorneys wrote in a court brief that the “legislature cannot override a constitutional provision with a statute.”
“Where a statute conflicts with our state constitution, we must follow our state constitution,” Dillon wrote in the opinion, joined by Judges Hunter Murphy and Jeff Carpenter. And such an error involving a jury trial can’t be set aside just because Chambers failed to object at the time, Dillon added.
State prosecutors could ask the state Supreme Court to consider Tuesday’s ruling.
veryGood! (752)
Related
- Tua Tagovailoa tackle: Dolphins QB laughs off taking knee to head vs. Rams on 'MNF'
- Kansas judge seals court documents in car chase that ended in officer’s shooting death
- Europe is cracking down on Big Tech. This is what will change when you sign on
- Man accused of beating goose to death with golf club at New York golf course, officials say
- Satire publication The Onion buys Alex Jones’ Infowars at auction with help from Sandy Hook families
- What’s More Harmful to Birds in North Dakota: Oil and Gas Drilling, or Corn and Soybeans?
- Vincennes University trustees vote to expand Red Skelton Performing Arts Center
- Prosecutors seek plea hearings for 2 West Virginia jail officers accused in inmate’s death
- Jana Kramer’s Ex Mike Caussin Shares Resentment Over Her Child Support Payments
- Everyone experiences intrusive thoughts. Here's how to deal with them.
Ranking
- Mike Tyson emerges as heavyweight champ among product pitchmen before Jake Paul fight
- Terry Funk, WWE wrestling icon, dies at 79
- Infrastructure turns into a theme in election-season speeches at Kentucky ham breakfast
- How 'Back to the Future: The Musical' created a DeLorean that flies
- Special counsel Smith asks court to pause appeal seeking to revive Trump’s classified documents case
- Angels two-way star Shohei Ohtani has UCL tear, won't pitch for rest of 2023 season
- New York Police: Sergeant suspended after throwing object at fleeing motorcyclist who crashed, died
- Biden proposes vast new marine sanctuary in partnership with California tribe
Recommendation
-
NBA players express concern for ex-player Kyle Singler after social media post
-
Takeaways of AP report on sexual misconduct at the CIA
-
When does 'The Morning Show' Season 3 come out? Release date, cast, trailer
-
Grand jury declines to indict officer in fatal Kentucky police shooting of armed Black man
-
Former NFL coach Jack Del Rio charged with operating vehicle while intoxicated
-
Gun control already ruled out, Tennessee GOP lawmakers hit impasse in session after school shooting
-
ACC college football preview: Can Florida State knock off Clemson?
-
Brooklyn man charged with murder in 'horrific' hammer attack on mother, 2 children